smodels.github.io

Validation plots for SModelS-v1.2.2

This page lists validation plots for all analyses and topologies available in the SMS results database that can be validated against official results. Fastlim results are listed; superseded results have been skipped. The list has been created from the database version 1.2.2, including the Fastlim tarball that is shipped separately. There is also a list of all analyses, and a list of all SMS topologies.

The validation procedure for upper limit maps used here is explained in arXiv:1312.4175, EPJC May 2014, 74:2868, section 4. For validating efficiency maps, a very similar procedure is followed. For every input point, the best signal region is chosen. The experimental upper limits are compared with the theoretical predictions for that signal region.

Individual tables

Run 2 - 13 TeV

Run 1 - 8 TeV

ATLAS upper limits, 13 TeV: 9 analyses, 15 results total

Result Txname L [1/fb] Validation plots comment
ATLAS-SUSY-2015-01 T2bb 3.2  
ATLAS-SUSY-2015-02 T2tt 3.2  
ATLAS-SUSY-2015-09 T1tttt 3.2  
ATLAS-SUSY-2016-14 T1ttofftt 36.1 in 1.2.2!
  T1tttt 36.1 in 1.2.2!
  T1ttttoff 36.1 in 1.2.2!
  T6ttWW 36.1 in 1.2.2!
ATLAS-SUSY-2016-17 T2bbWWoff 36.1 in 1.2.2!
  T2tt 36.1 in 1.2.2!
  T2ttoff 36.1 in 1.2.2!
ATLAS-SUSY-2016-19 T4bnutaubnutau 36.1 in 1.2.2!
ATLAS-SUSY-2016-26 T2cc 36.1 in 1.2.2!
ATLAS-SUSY-2016-33 T5ZZ 36.1

in 1.2.2!
  T6ZZ 36.1 in 1.2.2!
ATLAS-SUSY-2017-03 TChiWZ 36.1 in 1.2.2!

ATLAS efficiency maps, 13 TeV: 2 analyses, 3 results total

Result Txname L [1/fb] Validation plots comment
ATLAS-SUSY-2015-02 T2tt 3.2  
ATLAS-SUSY-2015-06 T1 3.2  
  T2 3.2 in 1.2.2! comment

CMS upper limits, 13 TeV: 28 analyses, 121 results total

Result Txname L [1/fb] Validation plots comment
CMS-PAS-EXO-16-036 THSCPM1b 12.9 comment
  TRHadGM1 12.9 comment
  TRHadQM1 12.9 comment
CMS-PAS-SUS-16-022 T1tttt 12.9  
  T1ttttoff 12.9  
CMS-PAS-SUS-16-052 T2bbWWoff 35.9  
  T6bbWWoff 35.9  
CMS-PAS-SUS-17-004 TChiWH 35.9  
  TChiWZ 35.9  
  TChiWZoff 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-032 T2bb 35.9  
  T2cc 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-033 T1 35.9  
  T1bbbb 35.9  
  T1tttt 35.9  
  T1ttttoff 35.9  
  T2 35.9  
  T2bb 35.9  
  T2tt 35.9  
  T2ttoff 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-034 T5ZZ 35.9
 
  TChiWZ 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-035 T1tttt 35.9  
  T1ttttoff 35.9  
  T5WW 35.9  
  T5WWoff 35.9  
  T5tctc 35.9  
  T5ttbbWWoff 35.9  
  T5tttt 35.9  
  T6ttWW 35.9  
  T6ttWWoff 35.9  
  T6ttoffWW 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-036 T1 35.9  
  T1bbbb 35.9  
  T1tttt 35.9  
  T1ttttoff 35.9  
  T2 35.9  
  T2bb 35.9  
  T2cc 35.9  
  T2tt 35.9  
  T2ttoff 35.9  
  T6bbWW 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-037 T1tttt 35.9  
  T1ttttoff 35.9  
  T5ttofftt 35.9  
  T5tttt 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-039 TChiChipmSlepL 35.9

 
  TChiChipmSlepStau 35.9

 
  TChiChipmStauStau 35.9  
  TChiWH 35.9  
  TChiWZ 35.9  
  TChiWZoff 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-041 T1tttt 35.9  
  T1ttttoff 35.9  
  T6HHtt 35.9  
  T6ZZofftt 35.9  
  T6ZZtt 35.9  
  T6ttWW 35.9  
  T6ttWWoff 35.9  
  T6ttoffWW 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-042 T1tttt 35.9  
  T1ttttoff 35.9  
  T5WW 35.9  
  T5WWoff 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-043 TChiWH 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-045 T6bbHH 35.9  
  TChiWH 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-046 T5gg 35.9
 
  T6gg 35.9
 
CMS-SUS-16-047 T5gg 35.9
 
  T6gg 35.9
 
CMS-SUS-16-049 T2cc 35.9  
  T2tt 35.9  
  T2ttC 35.9  
  T2ttoff 35.9  
  T6bbWW 35.9  
  T6bbWWoff 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-050 T1tttt 35.9  
  T1ttttoff 35.9    
  T2tt 35.9  
  T2ttoff 35.9    
  T5tctc 35.9  
  T5tttt 35.9  
CMS-SUS-16-051 T2tt 35.9  
  T2ttoff 35.9  
  T6bbWW 35.9  
CMS-SUS-17-001 T2tt 35.9  
  T2ttoff 35.9  
  T6bbWW 35.9  

CMS efficiency maps, 13 TeV: 2 analyses, 3 results total

Result Txname L [1/fb] Validation plots comment
CMS-PAS-EXO-16-036 THSCPM1b 12.9 comment
CMS-PAS-SUS-16-052-agg T2bbWWoff 35.9  
  T6bbWWoff 35.9  

ATLAS upper limits, 8 TeV: 28 analyses, 58 results total

Result Txname L [1/fb] Validation plots comment
ATLAS-CONF-2013-007 T1btbt 20.7  
  T1tttt 20.7  
  T5tttt 20.7 comment
  T6ttWW 20.7
comment
  T6ttWWoff 20.7  
ATLAS-CONF-2013-061 T1bbbb 20.1  
  T1btbt 20.1 comment
  T1tttt 20.1 comment
ATLAS-CONF-2013-089 T6WW 20.3
 
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-02 T1 20.3 comment
  T2 20.3  
  T5WW 20.3
 
  T5WWoff 20.3
 
  T5tctc 20.3  
  T6WW 20.3
comment
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-04 T1tttt 20.3  
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-05 T2bb 20.1  
  T6bbWW 20.1  
  T6bbWWoff 20.1

 
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-08 T6ZZtt 20.3  
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-09 T1tttt 20.3  
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-11 TChiWW 20.3  
  TChiWZ 20.3  
  TChipChimSlepSnu 20.3 comment
  TSlepSlep 20.3 comment
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-12 TChiChipmSlepL 20.3  
  TChiChipmStauL 20.3 comment
  TChiWH 20.3  
  TChiWZ 20.3  
  TChiWZoff 20.3  
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-15 T2tt 20.3 comment
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-16 T2tt 20.1  
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-18 T1bbbb 20.1  
  T1tttt 20.1 comment
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-19 T2bbWW 20.3  
  T2tt 20.3 comment
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-23 TChiWH 20.3  

ATLAS efficiency maps, 8 TeV: 15 analyses, 28 results total

Result Txname L [1/fb] Validation plots comment
ATLAS-CONF-2013-024 T2tt 20.5 in 1.2.2!
ATLAS-CONF-2013-037 T2tt 20.7 in 1.2.2!
ATLAS-CONF-2013-047 T1 20.3 in 1.2.2!
  T2 20.3 in 1.2.2!
  TGQ 20.3 in 1.2.2!
ATLAS-CONF-2013-048 T2tt 20.3 in 1.2.2!
ATLAS-CONF-2013-053 T2bb 20.1 in 1.2.2!
ATLAS-CONF-2013-061 T1bbbb 20.1 in 1.2.2!
  T1btbt 20.1 in 1.2.2!
  T1tttt 20.1 in 1.2.2!
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-02 T1 20.3  
  T2 20.3  
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-04 T1tttt 20.3  
  T5WW 20.3  
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-05 T2bb 20.1 comment
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-11 TChiWW 20.3 comment
  TChiWWoff 20.3  
  TChipChimSlepSnu 20.3 comment
  TSlepSlep 20.3  
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-15 T2tt 20.3  
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-16 T2tt 20.1  
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-18 T1bbbb 20.1  
  T1tttt 20.1  
ATLAS-SUSY-2013-21 T2cc 20.3  
  T2bb 20.3  
  T2bbWW 20.3  
  T2bbWWoff 20.3  
ATLAS-SUSY-2014-03 TScharm 20.3  

CMS upper limits, 8 TeV: 19 analyses, 68 results total

Result Txname L [1/fb] Validation plots comment
CMS-EXO-12-026 THSCPM1b 18.8 comment
  TRHadGM1 18.8 comment
  TRHadQM1 18.8 comment
CMS-PAS-SUS-13-016 T1tttt 19.7  
  T1ttttoff 19.7  
CMS-PAS-SUS-13-018 T2bb 19.4  
CMS-PAS-SUS-13-023 T2tt 18.9  
  T2ttoff 18.9  
  T6bbWW 18.9

 
  T6bbWWoff 18.9

comment
CMS-SUS-12-024 T1tttt 19.4  
  T1ttttoff 19.4  
CMS-SUS-12-028 T1 11.7  
  T1bbbb 11.7  
  T1tttt 11.7  
  T2 11.7  
  T2bb 11.7  
CMS-SUS-13-002 T1tttt 19.5  
CMS-SUS-13-004 T1bbbb 19.3  
  T1tttt 19.3  
  T1ttttoff 19.3  
  T2tt 19.3  
  T2ttoff 19.3  
CMS-SUS-13-006 TChiChipmSlepL 19.5

 
  TChiChipmSlepStau 19.5

 
  TChiWH 19.5 comment
  TChiWZ 19.5  
  TChiWZoff 19.5  
  TSlepSlep 19.5 comment
CMS-SUS-13-007 T1tttt 19.3  
  T1ttttoff 19.3  
  T5tttt 19.3
 
CMS-SUS-13-011 T2tt 19.5  
  T2ttoff 19.5  
  T6bbWW 19.5

 
  T6bbWWoff 19.5

 
CMS-SUS-13-012 T1 19.5  
  T1tttt 19.5  
  T1ttttoff 19.5  
  T2 19.5  
CMS-SUS-13-013 T1tttt 19.5  
  T1ttttoff 19.5  
  T6ttWW 19.5

 
  T6ttWWoff 19.5
 
CMS-SUS-13-019 T1 19.5  
  T1bbbb 19.5  
  T1tttt 19.5  
  T1ttttoff 19.5  
  T2 19.5  
  T2bb 19.5  
  T2tt 19.5  
  T2ttoff 19.5  
CMS-SUS-14-010 T1tttt 19.5  
  T1ttttoff 19.5  
CMS-SUS-14-021 T2bbWW 19.7  
  T2bbWWoff 19.7  

CMS efficiency maps, 8 TeV: 8 analyses, 20 results total

Result Txname L [1/fb] Validation plots comment
CMS-EXO-13-006 THSCPM1b 18.8 comment
CMS-PAS-SUS-13-015 T2tt 19.4  
  T2ttoff 19.4  
CMS-PAS-SUS-13-016 T1tttt 19.7  
  T1ttttoff 19.7  
CMS-SUS-12-024 T1bbbb 19.4  
  T1tttt 19.4  
  T1ttttoff 19.4  
CMS-SUS-13-007 T1tttt 19.3  
  T1ttttoff 19.3  
CMS-SUS-13-011 T2tt 19.5  
  T2ttoff 19.5  
CMS-SUS-13-012 T1 19.5  
  T1tttt 19.5  
  T1ttttoff 19.5  
  T2 19.5  
  T5WW 19.5  
  T5ZZ 19.5  
CMS-SUS-13-013 T1tttt 19.5  
  T1ttttoff 19.5